Tuesday, April 26, 2022

Fiddler on the Roof: Notes and Discussion Guide

printable version here

 Location 

Anatevka, Russia, in 1905: a small Jewish fictional village, located somewhere in the Pale of Settlement. (Jews weren’t allowed past those borders.)

Russia is ruled by Czar Nicholas II (Romanov dynasty) 


Characters 

All the characters in this story are fictional but based on stories of the time. 

Tevye: father, patriarch, milkman. He has a chatty and open relationship with God. 

Golde: his wife. Golde wants her daughters not to live in poverty. 

Tzeitel: oldest daughter, has arranged marriage to rich butcher Lazar, but chooses the poor tailor Motel instead

Hodel: second daughter, marries revolutionary radical Perchik

Chava: third daughter, marries Fyedka, a Christian man, so she is considered dead to family

Constable: Gentile law enforcement of town. He is friendly to Tevye but still looks down on Jews. He follows orders to terrorize and eventually evict the entire Jewish population of their small town. 

Judaism

Over 4,000 year old religion, culture, and people group.

Rabbi: faith leader of a community

Synagogue: meeting house for religious practice

Sabbath: Holy Day of rest. Begins Friday night at sundown and lasts until Saturday night at sundown.

Torah: Holy Book

In this story, there are many traditional gender roles, and community roles like arranged marriage and matchmakers. Touching the opposite gender was inappropriate, and touching gentiles (non-Jews) made you unclean. Some traditional communities still follow these practices.

Anti-semitism: hostility and prejudice against Jews. Russia (and other countries) at this time (and many other times) made anti-Jewish propaganda, and they enacted evictions and pogroms (organized killing of a minority). The pogroms in Russia and around the world culminated in the Holocaust (1941-1945) where 6 million Jews were murdered. 


Eastern Orthodox Christianity

11th Century: Schism with Roman Catholics (doesn’t follow the Catholic Pope.)

Common faith in Eastern Europe and Russia. 

Although they live in the same town as the Jewish characters, the movie shows different music and dance styles as an example of different cultures living side by side. 


Marxism

1848: Karl Marx writes “The Communist Manifesto” about class conflict between workers and business owners. The relationship is inherently exploitative, because the goal of capitalism is to make a profit. Marxism aims for fairness when the workers own the means of production and get rid of class differences. 

The character Perchik went to university in Kiev, where he probably learned these new ideas. He teaches his young students the Rachel and Leah story, and says the moral is “never trust an employer.” Perchik returns to Kiev to protest. He gets arrested Bloody Sunday Massacre, in which the Czar’s troops killed hundreds of unarmed protestors. He is sent to Siberia (central/east Russia, very cold and rural). 

Czar Nicholas made temporary parliament in response to allow changes. He abdicated in 1917 after the February Revolution. In
the same year, after the October Revolution, the Bolsheviks took power. They executed the Czar and his family in 1918. They formed the Soviet Union which lasted from 1922 - 1991. 


Discussion

Do you practice special family or cultural traditions? What are they?


How do you decide which traditions are worth keeping and which should go?


Is the Constable a friend to Tevye? What should people in power do to help the oppressed?


Anti-semitism is at the root of most conspiracy theories. How should Christians fight against this? 


Tevye wishes he could be a rich man; Golde wants her daughters out of poverty. Marxist Perchik thinks the rich are oppressors. How do these ideas conflict, and how could they agree?

Friday, April 15, 2022

Moloka'i: The Story of Father Damien, movie discussion guide


printable version of this guide

Locations 

Kalaupapa: small inaccessible part of island, a peninsula with high pali (cliffs).

Honolulu: the modern capital city of the sovereign Kingdom of Hawaii. 



Characters

Father Damien: missionary from Belgium called to serve lepers. Broke rules to show love. 

Rudolf Meyer: commissioner, supply agent. (Lives topside: walk or ride on a steep path up the cliff face)

Father Leonor: assisted kind Bishop Kockerman and later Bishop Maigret. Didn’t want to help Father Damien and claimed that he exaggerated. 

Clayton Strawn: new manager of rations. Unethical, but repented later after he went blind.

William Williamson: British Protestant medical assistant who contracted leprosy from patients. 

Prime Minister Gibson: served Hawaiian government under King Kalakaua. angry about finances of Molokai. 

Dr. Kalewis: brought experimental medicine. Couldn’t commit to stay

Princess Lili’uokalani: visited lepers, wrote Aloha Oe which she sings in this movie

Mother Marianne: worked at New York hospital, called to Hawaii. Worked at Kalaupapa until she died age 80. None of her nuns were ever infected (they focused on cleanliness).


Historical Events

1778: Captain Cook and Western world come to Hawaii, bringing many diseases. More 

than half of the native population dies in the following decades. 

1830s: first suspected cases of leprosy in Hawaii. 

Christianity has become main religion of Hawaiians.

1866: leper colony established by King Kamehameha V.

1873: mission begins, Damien is 33.

1877: Princess Lili’uokalani visits Kalaupapa  

1883: Mother Marianne and six nuns travel to Honolulu

1884: Father Damien contracts leprosy

1888: nuns allowed to come to Molokai

1889: Father Damien dies, age 49

1940: a cure is developed

1969: isolation law repealed

2009: Damien sainted


Medical notes on Hansen’s Disease (Leprosy):

caused by a bacteria, damages skin, nerves, and eyes. Patients get rashes and lose feeling in their extremities. Lose fingers, toes, noses, ears, or more. Blindness, damaged skin

Misunderstanding: Contagiousness is actually very low, and not everyone is vulnerable to it. Spread by coughing and mucus, but historically, people thought, don’t touch and don’t share food. Not an STI.

Emotional: forgotten by family, children raised by strangers, prison-like. Judged for their poverty, unclean, untrustworthy, and morally corrupt. Spreads more in poor areas, still exists in poor countries today. In leper colonies, “Boredom is worst punishment”

Hawaii banished more than 8,000 lepers to Molokai over the years. Around 1,000 on island at a time during Damien’s service years

Biblical references: Leviticus 14:54–57: A wide range of skin conditions were called leprosy in ancient times. Jesus heals lepers in Matthew 8:1-4, Mark 1:40-45, and Luke 5:12-16. 


Catholicism

Sacraments: Baptism, Confirmation, Eucharist (communion), Reconciliation, Anointing of the Sick, Matrimony (Marriage), and Holy Orders (becoming a priest or nun.). 

Last Rites is a ritual performed for the dying. 

Confession is when you tell your sins to a priest, then he gives you absolution (forgiveness.)

Saints: The Catholic church designates some people as saints, in honor of their work on earth, and identified by miracles after their death.

Vows: Priests and nuns take vows of celibacy (lifelong abstinence from sex) and poverty. If they break the rules, they can be unfrocked (authority removed, special clothes taken.) In this story, we meet a Brother who has taken a vow of Penitence. He has committed a sin, and part of his remorse includes some challenge or manual labor to make up for the harm he caused. 

No divorce and remarriage: without special permission. (another rule Father Damien breaks)

Protestants: Christians who aren’t Catholic. Protestants protested corruption in the church in the 1500s. They broke off to become a new group, which splintered into many groups, called 

Protestant Denominations: Lutherans, Congregationalists, Baptists, Methodists, Presbyterians and more. Many Christians today called themselves “non-denominational.”


Cultural Notes

Mourning in Polynesian cultures is loud, public, and communal. 

Hiding a leper was a crime: you were arrested, possibly sent away without saying bye. However, there were times on Molokai where family members could choose to come along as helpers.


Discussion Questions

Malulani tells Father Damien she’s entitled to the good life when he finds her at the mad house, where lepers drink and party. Damien disagrees on what a good life entails.What is The Good Life? 


Lepers struggled not just due to illness, but how they were treated by their society. Some people believe that those who are sick or poor must be getting what they deserve. Where do we see this in our world today? What is God’s heart for the sick and poor?


Father Damien did so much work alone. Sometimes he got state support and sometimes church support. Who should fix the problems of the world? Church? State? Individuals? 

Tuesday, April 12, 2022

Princess Ka'iulani Movie Discussion Guide

This page is available to print from google docs

Location:

Story starts at ‘Iolani Palace, Honolulu in the sovereign nation of Hawaii. Ka’iulani spends her teen years in England, then visits America before returning home. 



Characters:

Princess Ka’iulani: niece of the king. Scottish father, Hawaiian mother. English family calls her Victoria, a middle name.

King David Kalakaua: educated, traveled, modern King. Built palace. wife Queen Kapiolani. 

Princess/Queen Lili’uokalani: Sister of King David Kalakaua. (Ka’iulani also calls her Aunt Lydia.) Educated, musician, singer, composer. Devoted Christian

Archibald Cleghorn: Ka’iulani’s father. Scottish. late wife: Princess Mariam Likelike. 

Lorrin Thurston: son of American missionaries to Hawaii. Leader of the anti-monarchy movement. Lawyer, member of legislature.  

Sanford Dole: cousin of James Dole, who started Dole Pineapple Plantation. Became President of Hawaii during the overthrow, then Governor after annexation. Dole is portrayed positively in this movie, but he goes along with everything Thurston does and personally benefits from it. 

Theo Davies: Ka’iulani lives with this family friend in England. He owns HI sugar plantations.

Fictional characters: the Hawaiian twins, Clive the boyfriend.


Major events:

1778 Western world comes to Hawaii: Captain James Cook comes to Hawaii

1820 Christian missionaries come to Hawaii.

1886 Palace electrified

1887 Bayonet constitution (King David Kalakaua forced to sign at gunpoint.)

1888 Honolulu streets electrified, Kaiulani throws the switch (age 12)

1889 Ka’iulani sent to England for education

1891 King David died age 54, sister Lili’uokalani becomes Queen, writes a new

        constitution.

1893 overthrow begins, Queen Lili’uokalani placed under house arrest. 

1985 Rebellion. Queen Lili’uokalani put on trial and convicted of treason. 

        Ka’iulani visits US President Cleveland (age 17)

1897 Natives petition against annexation

1898 President McKinley: US annexes HI

1899 Ka’iulani dies, age 23

1900 Hawaii becomes a territory, Dole is governor 

1917 Queen Lili’uokalani dies, age 79

1941 Japan attacks Pearl Harbor in Honolulu, spurring US to join WWII

1959 Hawaii becomes 50th state

1993 US President Clinton gives formal apology for the annexation


Cultural notes:

Victorian time period (named for British Monarch, Queen Victoria.) Full-coverage dresses, and ankles are scandalous! The Hawaiian royal family dresses like westerners despite the tropical climate. Ka’iulani goes over the top with manners, decor etc. to prove that she’s just as “civilized” as the westerners. King David Kalakaua and Queen Lili’uokalani travel the world, exchange gifts with other royalty, build a modern palace, and pursue education and refinement. Yet, it’s not enough for America to respect their independence and stop pursuing greed. 

Biracial Ka’iulani is valued for being pretty according to white beauty standards (Queen Lili’uokalani doesn’t get same respect)

Queen Kapiolani and Princess Lili’uokalani attended Queen Victoria’s Golden Jubilee in 1887.

England: often sent children away to boarding school. England once overthrew Hawaii: but they stopped and apologized. As an act of friendship, Hawaii incorporated the British flag.



Hawaii: had nearly a100% literacy rate: the best in the world! In this movie, the commoner twin writing a letter to the Princess makes sense. Hawaii chose to have electrical energy before Buckingham Palace and Washington DC. King David Kalakaua was a world traveler who befriended Thomas Edison. Before the western world came to Hawaii, land was divided by community, not private ownership. White land-owners had sugar and pineapple plantations; the natives don’t own their ancestral land. 


Hawaiian Words: 

ali’i: chiefs, leaders, royalty

ola: life, sometimes health

kanaka: native people

poi: ground up taro (kalo) root - a purple paste 

Ua Mau ke Ea o ka ʻĀina i ka Pono: May the life of the land be perpetuated in righteousness. 


Discussion Guide

  1. Thurston says only white men with property should vote, but “I look forward to other races being able to govern someday.” Sometimes we don’t recognize racism. How can we learn to see more clearly?

  2. When missionaries came to Hawaii, they didn’t just bring Jesus. They brought modern Western culture. This included some good things, like a written language. But they also got rid of Hawaiian dancing, clothing, and many cultural practices. Is there a right way for missionaries to interact with a different culture?